Sunday, 26 May 2013

Study links health symptoms to CSG

By John Mikkelsen 
First published at the Queensland Telegraph.
AN ALARMING report into possible health effects of coal seam gas developments on a Surat Basin community has been presented to the Queensland Government by a Brisbane GP. 

The study by Dr Geralyn McCarron, found a higher than normal level of possible neurotoxicity, including numbness, spasms and twitching, as well as muscle soreness, nose bleeds, rashes and vomiting, particularly among children living in the Tara residential estates close to gas wells 
Photo & graphs below sourced from Dr McCarron's report

This settlement on the Darling Downs is part of an extensive area being developed by coal seam gas companies to supply the three multi-billion dollar export liquefied natural gas plants under construction on Curtis Island near Gladstone. 

 Dr McCarron, originally from Ireland, told The Telegraph she had decided to undertake the study “completely independently” after learning of health problems reported by families living close to the gas wells and a subsequent Queensland Government report claiming there were no significant health problems linked to CSG. 

She said the government study and findings were “so inadequate and flawed that it has done little to alleviate concerns” 

A copy of her report and recommendations including calls for fully funded urgent and comprehensive health studies in gas field areas, was presented to Health Minister Lawrence Springborg’s office on May 9.

 Titled, “Symptomatology of a gas field - An independent health survey in the Tara rural residential estates and environs,” the study involved collecting information on 113 people from 38 households - 17 were children 5 years of age or less, 31 were aged between 6 and 18, and 65 were adults aged over 19.
Dr McCarron said 58%  reported  their health was definitely adversely affected by CSG, with 19% uncertain.
“The pattern reported was outside the scope of what would be expected for a small rural community. In all age groups there were reported increases in cough, chest  tightness, rashes, difficulty sleeping, joint pains, muscle pains and spasms, nausea and vomiting.  
“Approximately one third of the people over 6 were reported to have spontaneous nose bleeds, and almost three quarters were reported to have skin irritation. Over half of children were reported to have eye irritation.  
“A range of symptoms were reported which can sometimes be related to neurotoxicity (damage to the nervous system), including severe fatigue, weakness, headaches, numbness and paraesthesia (abnormal sensations such as pins and needles, burning or tingling). Approximately a third of the all the 48 children to age 18 were reported to experience paraesthesia. Almost all the 31 children aged 6-18 were reported to suffer from headaches and for over half of these the headaches were severe.  
“Of people aged 6 years and over, severe fatigue and difficulty concentrating was reported for over half. Parents of a number of young children reported twitching or unusual movements, and clumsiness or unsteadiness.  
“This unfunded study is limited in terms of what can be concluded and does not claim to be without methodological problems. However what it does do is highlight the basis for serious concerns of the residents and the need for the Queensland government to fund a comprehensive epidemiological investigation of the problem,” the report states. 
Dr McCarron claims no baseline air, water monitoring or health studies were done prior to the Queensland Government permitting the widespread development of the CSG industry close to family homes.  
“No ongoing health study or surveillance and no ongoing testing to monitor chronic exposure levels is in place. This is clearly unacceptable,” she said.  

Springborg, Lawrence

But Mr Springborg told The Telegraph that a  comprehensive inter-departmental report, tabled in Parliament, provided “the best available data and robust advice on the effects of Coal Seam Gas on the health of Tara residents”.

Photo sourced from Qld Parliament member list

He said the report, based on data from local practitioners, occupational health experts, published papers and departmental advice, found no clear link between CSG activities and residents’ health complaints.
“The low number of individuals reporting symptoms was among the reasons for the finding. The estimated population for the exposure area was 1,257 people. Forty-six residents, or 3.7 per cent, reported symptoms,” Mr Springborg said.
He claimed the report by Dr  McCarron, “on behalf of anti-CSG groups”, contained nothing new, but a number of assertions which lacked substance and did not detract from the tabled findings.
The State Government report made six recommendations:
  •  A coordinated response by Government agencies, including a community reference group to help identify health, community and social concerns
  •  The introduction of community support initiatives in affected areas
Future health clinics in the Tara region, with community input about their nature, location, frequency and timing - including strategies to address aspects of mental health
  •  Regular, timely and accurate feedback to communities in relation to health, community and social concerns, including reports on air monitoring
The continuation of air monitoring by the Department of Environment and Heritage Protection to identify emissions and the extent of community exposure
  • The possibility of measures to monitor and mitigate exposure to low frequency noise.



  1. Following the release of Dr McCarron's report the conservative organisation representing in the vicinity 27000 doctors in Australia, the Australian Medical Association have issued a policy resolution.

    "That Federal Council adopts the policy resolution urging governments to ensure that:
    •all existing coal seam gas extraction projects are regularly monitored for any health impacts and the presence of air and ground-water pollutants in their local environment; and,
    •all future proposals for coal seam gas mining are subject to rigorous and independent health risk assessments, which take into account the potential for exposure to pollutants through air and groundwater and any likely associated health risks. In circumstances where there is insufficient evidence to ensure safety, the precautionary principle should apply."

  2. Broadcaster Alan Jones interviewed Dr McCarron; to go to the audio link [click here]

  3. As usual, the official line is there is no serious health link - just like the Gladstone fishermen who got sick or developed serious infections which they blamed on infected fish and polluted water. They also say the mine water releases into the Fitzroy system is no cause for concern even tho it supplies Rockhampton's drinking water and chlorination does nor remove chemical toxins.
    Mr Springborg says only three percent of residents reported health effects in the Tara area but from what I'm told, the govt medicos did not visit tany homes near the gasfields, only major towns in the area and their visits were not widely advertised.

    1. If the Government spent as much money on proper honest independent studies of the problems as they spend trying to cover up the real problems then perhaps we might get to see the real problem warts and all.

      At the moment all of the warts seem to be on the Politicians and CEO's noses and they are obstructing the view of everything beyond the end of their noses.

      Maybe we should put a few of them into cages and leave them out in the middle of the Tara Area and make them drink only Fitzroy River water from the upper reaches of the river.

  4. Hi Peter you forgot "... and eat fish and prawns from the healthy Gladstone Harbour with its great water quality..."

  5. The Australian Medical Association has come out with a strong statement about CSG & human health; If in doubt, turn CSG off: AMA


Welcome to a place that has a focus (but not exclusively) on regional and rural Australia open for anyone living anywhere to read, learn and interact. Please feel free to make a comment.

You can use some HTML codes such as, a for active; b for bold; i for italics

Active code - substitute a for @
<@ href="web address">linked words

[Click Here] for a link to another site where there is a very good simple explanation.